In party disagreements

For an article I wrote for Pluto, I spoke to Councillor John Swindells about ID cards for students. He's the Labour councillor for the University ward of Preston. Here's the full statement he gave me.

"I have no real problem with ID cards as such.

If the technology is proven then we could have a useful tool to prevent Identity theft and ensure that loans, benefits etc get to the correct people. However my real concern with the card which will use similar technology as passports and driving licence is the proposed cost of the card. As a dad to 2 sons who have both recently achieved degrees from Nottingham & UCLan University's and a daughter who is a 2nd year student at UCLan I am really concern about adding any extra financial burden on to students.The loan is a real disincentive for poorer students being able to attend University.

Any ID card to access a student loan would in my view be unjustified and an ID card to get a loan should be free and come with the loan.

There will be a need to charge for the ID card to the general public only if is a similar price as other documents people use on a daily basis. The ID card should be phased in as driving licences and passports are renewed as you currently pay for those documents. "

I think it's great to see a councillor speaking honestly, and with some actual experience and authority, without spin, and unafraid of going against his party's wishes. Granted, he isn't exactly a minister, and he knew that he was talking to a student newspaper reporter, but still, it's good to hear some honesty without spin. Ain't democracy great?